Kids ATV vs Ride-On Car for a 5-Year-Old
A ride-on car suits a 5-year-old who needs parental control. An ATV suits one who wants to ride outdoors on rougher ground. Compared by speed, weight limit and control.
Affiliate Disclosure
This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, PowerWheels HQ may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Our reviews and recommendations are editorially independent.
For a 5-year-old, a ride-on car is the better choice if a parental remote matters, and an ATV is the better choice if the child steers well and will ride mainly on grass. The Kid Trax 12V ATV lists a 2.7 mph top speed and a 77 lb limit, which is similar to a typical 12V ride-on car. 24V ATVs list 5-7.5 mph, so they're closer to a step up than a swap.
Side by Side
- Control: many cars include a parental remote; most ATVs don't.
- Speed: 12V ATV 2.7 mph; 24V ATV 5-7.5 mph (listed).
- Terrain: ATVs with larger tires are better on grass; cars with plastic tires are better on pavement.
- Weight limit: about 77 lbs on a 12V ATV; 130+ lbs on many two-seat 24V cars and large ATVs.
- Feel: a 5-year-old often finds an ATV more grown-up than a car.
Which to Choose
If the child is new to ride-ons, start with a car with a remote. If they have driven a ride-on already and the yard is grass, the ATV is a good step.
Quick Comparison
Kid Trax 12V ATV
Kid Trax
ATV for a cautious 5-year-old
- Voltage
- 12V
- Seats
- 1
- Ages
- 3–8 years
- Price
- $200
Best Choice Products 24V 2-Seater Ride-On Car with Parent Remote
Best Choice Products
Car with a parent remote
- Voltage
- 24V
- Seats
- 2
- Ages
- 3+ years
- Price
- $300
| Product | Best For | Specs | Price | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Kid Trax 12V ATV Kid Trax | ATV for a cautious 5-year-old | 12V · 1 seat Ages 3–8 years | $200 | 4.2 |
Best Choice Products 24V 2-Seater Ride-On Car with Parent Remote Best Choice Products | Car with a parent remote | 24V · 2 seats Ages 3+ years | $300 | 4.2 |
Prices are approximate and subject to change. Always verify current pricing before purchasing.
Our Picks — In Detail
Kid Trax 12V ATV
Kid Trax
12VSeats
1Ages
3–8 yearsPrice
$200
Listed 2.7 mph, 77 lb limit, 1-2 hours of play per charge.
Pros
- Low speed
- ATV styling
Cons
- No parental remote listed
Best Choice Products 24V 2-Seater Ride-On Car with Parent Remote
Best Choice Products
24VSeats
2Ages
3+ yearsPrice
$300
Listed with a parent remote, 90-minute runtime and a 132 lb capacity. Price seen Oct 27, 2026: $299.99.
Pros
- Parental remote
- Two seats
Cons
- Larger than a single-seat ATV
What to Look For
Voltage (6V / 12V / 24V)
Higher voltage means more power, higher top speed, and better terrain handling. Choose based on your child's age, size, and where they'll ride. 12V is the most popular choice for ages 3–7.
Number of Seats
Single-seat models work for one child; two-seat designs are great for siblings or friends. Two-seaters often put more strain on the motor, so look for adequate power.
Terrain
Most 12V ride-ons handle flat grass and hard surfaces. If you have hills, rough grass, or gravel, look for 24V models with high-traction tires.
Safety Features
Look for seat belts, parental lockout switches, low/high speed settings, and parental remote controls — especially for younger or first-time riders.
Battery & Charging
Check battery life (usually 1–2 hours for 12V) and charge time (8–18 hours). Some premium models offer faster charging or higher-capacity batteries.